Peanut the Squirrel, an eastern gray squirrel rescued in 2017 by Mark Longo and later joined by Fred the raccoon, became an Instagram star. Find out more in the article below.
Raid, Execution, and Rabies Testing
On October 30, 2024, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) executed a five-hour raid on the couple’s home, seizing both animals. Authorities claimed Peanut bit one of their agents—even through thick leather gloves—triggering the decision to euthanize and behead both for post-mortem rabies testing. Rabies tests for both were negative, yet neither the animals’ remains were returned nor an apology issued by the state.
Claims of Government Overreach and Trauma
In early 2025, the grieving couple filed two lawsuits: one on June 27 in Chemung County Supreme Court (seeking unspecified damages), and another on August 7 in the Court of Claims, now demanding $10 million. Their legal documents argue the killings were not justified by rabies fears but were “a senseless act of violence” and an “obscene demonstration of government abuse”. They describe profound emotional trauma, as well as financial loss—Peanut had become a monetized online personality, featuring on social media, Cameos, and even OnlyFans.
Criticism and Regulatory Reforms
Experts criticized New York’s actions. Rabies specialist Dr. Edward R. Rensimer labeled the decision to kill and decapitate the animals “insane,” noting that squirrels virtually never carry rabies and suggesting a humane 10-day quarantine would have sufficed. Public outcry led the DEC to review its protocols. Under the leadership of Acting Commissioner Amanda Lefton, changes such as body cameras for agents and updated wildlife seizure procedures were announced five months after the incident.
Political Firestorm and Cultural Fallout
Peanut’s death sparked national debate. His case became a symbol of perceived government overreach, attracting remarks from Republican figures and social media users. Prominent individuals, including Elon Musk, criticized the authorities. Musk posted, “They arrested (and killed) Peanut, but have not even tried to file charges against anyone on the Epstein client list. Government is deeply broken.”.The incident also inspired proposed legislation—dubbed “Peanut’s Law”—to limit government authority in animal seizure cases.
Continuing Public Impact
Months after the incident, Peanut’s story continues to spark conversations across social media and in political circles. Animal rights advocates have rallied behind the couple, using the case as a rallying cry for stronger protections for domesticated and rescued wildlife. Supporters have organized petitions, fundraising campaigns, and public demonstrations outside government offices in Albany. The couple, meanwhile, has become reluctant public figures in the fight for reform, often appearing in interviews to keep Peanut’s memory alive. They hope their legal battle will not only bring justice for Peanut and Fred, but also prevent similar tragedies from happening in the future.
Summary: From Internet Furball to Landmark Lawsuit
Peanut the Squirrel’s trajectory—from rescued orphan to internet star—ended tragically when state authorities seized and euthanized him and his friend Fred without rabies confirmation or humane alternatives. The consequences have rippled—legal, political, and cultural—and now may cost New York State up to $10 million in damages. The case continues to fuel debates over wildlife regulation, individual rights, and government accountability.
