The 97th Academy Awards, held on March 2, 2025, became a focal point of controversy due to the omission of several notable figures from its “In Memoriam” segment. Among the most discussed absences was that of actress Michelle Trachtenberg, whose exclusion sparked significant outrage among fans and industry peers alike.
Michelle Trachtenberg’s Career and Untimely Death
Michelle Trachtenberg was a versatile actress whose career spanned television and film. She gained prominence as a child actress with her role in “Harriet the Spy” (1996) and continued to build a diverse portfolio with performances in “Buffy the Vampire Slayer,” “Gossip Girl,” “Ice Princess,” and “EuroTrip.” Her ability to transition seamlessly between genres showcased her range and dedication to her craft.
Tragically, Trachtenberg was found dead in her Manhattan apartment on February 26, 2025, at the age of 39. Initial reports indicated that her body was discovered by her mother, and while no foul play was suspected, the exact cause of death remained undetermined due to the family’s objection to an autopsy. Speculations arose that her death might have been related to complications from a liver transplant she had undergone the previous year.
The Oscars’ “In Memoriam” Segment and the Backlash
The “In Memoriam” segment is a longstanding tradition at the Oscars, honoring members of the film industry who have passed away in the preceding year. During the 2025 ceremony, the segment featured tributes to several luminaries, including Maggie Smith, James Earl Jones, David Lynch, and Gene Hackman, who had died just days before the event.
However, the omission of Michelle Trachtenberg from this segment did not go unnoticed. Fans and colleagues expressed their disappointment and anger on social media platforms. One user wrote, “Oh f*** y’all for not including Michelle Trachtenberg. So disrespectful,” while another commented, “Michelle Trachtenberg not being mentioned in the in memoriam section of the Oscars is upsetting. You are and will remain so, so loved and admired, Michelle.”
Other Notable Omissions
Trachtenberg was not the only notable figure excluded from the segment. Actors such as Tony Todd, Shannen Doherty, Olivia Hussey, and Bernard Hill were also absent from the televised tribute. Tony Todd, renowned for his role in the “Candyman” series, was found dead in his home in late November 2024 at the age of 69. Shannen Doherty, known for her work in “Beverly Hills, 90210” and “Charmed,” succumbed to breast cancer in July 2024 at 53. Olivia Hussey, famed for her role in “Romeo and Juliet,” passed away in December 2024 at 73 after battling breast cancer.
The Academy’s Selection Process and Criticisms
The process of selecting individuals for the “In Memoriam” segment is overseen by a confidential executive committee comprising members from the Academy’s 19 branches. Factors influencing inclusion often encompass the individual’s prominence in film over television, their award history, and occasionally, subjective biases. Oscar winners or those who received Governors Awards are typically prioritized for inclusion.
This selection process has been a subject of contention over the years, with critics arguing that it lacks transparency and often overlooks deserving individuals. The exclusion of actors like Trachtenberg and Todd has reignited debates about the criteria and decision-making involved.
Reactions from the Entertainment Community
The omissions prompted reactions from various quarters of the entertainment industry. Sarah Michelle Gellar, who co-starred with Trachtenberg in “Buffy the Vampire Slayer,” shared an emotional tribute, referencing a poignant line from the show’s season 5 finale: “Michelle, listen to me. Listen. I love you. I will always love you. The hardest thing in this world, is to live in it. I will be brave. I will live… for you.”
Horror enthusiasts were particularly vocal about Tony Todd’s exclusion, viewing it as a broader snub of the horror genre by prestigious award ceremonies. Discussions on platforms like Reddit highlighted sentiments that the Oscars continue to undervalue contributions from the horror community, despite its significant cultural impact.
The Academy’s Response and Moving Forward
As of now, the Academy has not issued an official statement addressing the specific omissions from the 2025 “In Memoriam” segment. In previous instances, the Academy has acknowledged the challenges inherent in curating the segment, given time constraints and the vast number of industry losses each year. They often direct audiences to the Oscars’ official website, where a more comprehensive list of the departed is maintained.
The recurring controversies surrounding the “In Memoriam” segment underscore the need for a more transparent and inclusive selection process. Implementing clearer criteria and perhaps expanding the segment’s duration could ensure that deserving individuals are rightfully honored. Such measures would not only pay proper tribute to those who have contributed to the film industry but also resonate with audiences who seek acknowledgment for their beloved stars.
Conclusion
The exclusion of Michelle Trachtenberg and other notable figures from the 2025 Oscars’ “In Memoriam” segment has sparked widespread debate and highlighted perceived shortcomings in the Academy’s approach to honoring industry members. As fans and colleagues continue to voice their discontent, it remains imperative for the Academy to reflect on these criticisms and strive for a more equitable and transparent commemoration process in future ceremonies.
